Witchlight Part 18: The Grand Finale
Posted on Sep 26, 2026 in Tales from the Table. Last updated on Sep 28, 2026.
Part of a series called The Wild Beyond the Witchlight.
The group had just begun exploring the Palace of Heart’s Desire.
Date: September 26, 2026
Characters present
- Farvex Dusk: human warlock
- LiROARidas: leonin monk
- Shadow Claw: tabaxi cleric
- Philomena Gainsborough: centaur wizard
- Eiri: spiritling barbarian
Character level: 7
But First
With Shadow’s player having been absent last session, we didn’t play out the part where the gang went to the shadow theater to reclaim his shadow. Thus, we started with that this time. Let’s rewind time and return to Motherhorn!
After defeating Endelyn, Shadow had found himself drawn to the hall in the castle known as the shadow theater. He and the rest of the group went there, finding a small stage with shadowy creatures putting on a silent play. Shadow immediately recognized one of the shadows as his own. He ran up to it.
“Are you my shadow?” he asked.
The shadow looked surprised. It threw its hands up and looked around in confusion. When Shadow touched it, it twisted and morphed into the shape of a cloak, falling to the ground. As Shadow kneeled to pick it up, he found that his shadow was back where it belonged. He rose, put the cloak on, and waved his tail in the light to make sure his shadow followed his movements. It did. He was whole again. Also, his sick new cloak allowed him to teleport as long as he stood in shadowy places. Nice.
“What if you picked someone else’s shadow?” asked LiROARidas1. “Wouldn’t that be funny?”
“I can’t imagine walking around with, say, a gnome’s shadow,” said Vex. “That’d be so embarrassing.”
“Yeah, what if it were you, LiROARidas,” said Philomena. “Imagine if you had someone else’s shadow—if you were stuck with the shape of someone else following you around forever. What if it were a naked woman? Imagine if you were always being followed by a naked woman, LiROARidas. How would that make you feel?”
LiROARidas thought for a moment. “I think I’d be pretty pleased with that.”
“Yeah, So would I,” said Philomena.
They discovered that attacking the remaining shadows would send them back to their rightful owners, so they hacked and slashed at all the shadows in the theater. Eiri slashed one so hard that its owner, a goblin—specifically the mother of the kite-flying goblin kid—who was standing on a walkway high up in the ceiling, died and fell to the ground with a loud crash. On closer inspection, it turns out she survived. Maybe. Or it might just have been Vex holding up her head and moving her jaw while talking in a goblin voice. Either way, at least she got her shadow back.
But Second
With that out of the way, the story now returns to the Palace of Heart’s Desire. But not all the way back—we did another little flashback because it turns out there were a few rooms adjoining the ones we’d already visited that we’d missed in the last session’s haste, so the DM let us rewind and explore them now, with the whole party present.
The group was making its way up a spiral staircase in the palace. Vex suddenly remembered that there was something he’d forgotten to ask LiROARidas.
“LiROARidas, how exactly did you lose your eyesight?” said Vex. “This whole time we thought they took it because you snuck in at the carnival.”
“Well, after that I got scared,” said LiROARidas. “I ran straight into a cleaner who spilled bleach into my eyes.”
“Did the cleaner also go blind?” asked Philomena.
“No, her arms just got bleached a bit,” said LiROARidas.
“How would you know if you couldn’t see?”
“Uuuh…”
The party arrived in a circular room, built entirely from marble, with a pedestal in the middle. A white box sat atop it. Philomena, despite the bad experience of getting rickrolled the last time she opened a box, went up and looked inside. She saw a large, white gemstone, radiating a comfortable warmth. Shadow’s incredible sense of intuition told him it probably contained Zybilna’s will to do good to those in need.
In another similar room in another similar tower, they found a similar pedestal carrying a similar box. However, this box was black. Philomena, having regained her confidence in her ability to open boxes without nasty (but surprisingly catchy) surprises, opened it. Inside was another gemstone, but this one was black, much like the box, and radiated a faint glow instead of heat. This time, Shadow hypothesized that it represented Zybilna’s will to know the plans of her enemies. The party wasn’t sure what to make of that.
No More Buts
With the flashbacking over, the group was once again back in the room with Igrik, Zybilna’s toad familiar. As noted last time, he did have more to say. While he didn’t know how to free Zybilna, he suspected that Thinnings, the butler, might be able to help. Thinnings was the paper-thin dude they’d met last time, and he had not been cooperative whatsoever. But Igrik said that one of his friends in the palace, who was a spoon, would often speak to Thinnings by using a specific rhyme, and sharing a secret. The rhyme was as follows:
Slip underneath the doorway,
Then fold and disappear.
That’s where you’ll be hiding
Whenever I am near.
But I have something for you,
A thing you don’t yet know.
I’ll tell you my great secret
If only you will show.
With the rhyme written down, the party thanked Igrik, and headed for the servants’ quarters once more. Once there, Vex recited the rhyme, because no one else wanted to. Thinnings slipped out from his hiding place and returned to normal, human thickness. He looked at Vex and waited.
“Well?” he asked. “What’s the secret?”
“When I was eleven years old,” said Vex, “my mom told me I couldn’t play with fire magic because I might burn something down. But I did it anyway, and accidentally set fire to the carpet. I told her that the dog had knocked over a candle so she wouldn’t get mad at me.”
“Huh, that’s a pretty good secret. I guess I can trust you.”
“I have a secret too,” said Philomena. “I like women.”
“We know,” said everyone at once.
Thinnings shared what useful information he knew, which was quite a bit. First of all, Zybilna had a book that, if you sign your name into it, let you open every door in the palace. It could be reached from the teleportation room upstairs. Also, the jabberwock was a defender of the palace. He would often sleep inside, but could be lured away with music. It wasn’t that he enjoyed listening to music or anything, it just made him curious. He’d usually end up eating the performers. But he wasn’t the biggest and baddest bitch on the block, oh no. That title belonged to one Bloodybeak, who was a giant owl. Fortunately, he was frozen in time like most of the palace residents.
Speaking of frozen residents, Thinnings explained that there was a way to free them. All you had to do was touch them with a unicorn horn and say their true name. There was one problem, however—Zybilna’s true name wasn’t Zybilna. Thinnings didn’t know what it was, but it was a closely kept secret. She had some private rooms upstairs by her water corridor, just past the teleportation room, that might hold clues to her true name.
Finally, Iggwilv’s cauldron, the one the hags had used to cast their spell, was in the ballroom, along with a frozen Zybilna. The League of Malevolence were supposed to protect the cauldron, but struggled to do so because the ballroom was the jabberwock’s favorite room in the palace. And if the party needed to fight the jabberwock, there was a special sword, a vorpal sword called Snicker-Snack, that could be used to kill him. It was in the vault on the top floor of the central tower.
The Twist
The Beatles were there to free Zybilna, and to do so, they needed her true name. They went up the stairs, through a bunch of fancy marble corridors, past the teleportation room, which looked pretty ordinary save for four wooden hatches on one of the walls, and into the water corridor.
The water corridor was exactly what it sounded like—a corridor with water instead of floor. Unlike the outside, this water wasn’t frozen in time. Peering into it, the group saw faces contorted in agony deep below the surface, and glimpses of distant realms. They decided not to touch it. They didn’t have to, because a boat came along and guided them to a set of two doors.
Stepping through one of the doors, the group found themselves in another marble room. There was a terrible stench of rot in the air, and the ground was covered in crawling maggots. In the center stood seven wooden cradles holding seven deformed, demonic babies. Shadow’s newfound supernatural intuition informed him that these were manifestations of repressed negative emotions.
“Well, it looks pretty messed up, but it can’t be so bad, right?” asked Vex. “I mean, if Zybilna is repressing her negative emotions, that just means she’s full of good, right?”
“Yeah… Should we throw them in the river?” asked Philomena. “Keeping them here seems so cruel.”
“Not as cruel as throwing them in the river,” said Vex.
Above each abominable child hung a baby mobile depicting an elvish letter. Each one was different. It seemed like a puzzle of some sort. Vex took them down and placed them on a relatively clean part of the floor. The letter “z” was there, and the group quickly figured they could spell Zybilna. With the remaining letters, the group found a few different combinations:
Zybilna, ha, Santa
Zybilna, ha, Satan
Zybilna has a tan
Zybilna’s hat, naa
And my personal favorite:

But it didn’t take long for the group to find what they suspected was the correct combination:
Zybilna, Natasha.
Natasha, as in Tasha. Tasha the Witch Queen. Tasha with the hideous laughter. Was that Zybilna’s true name? Could the archfey of kindness be the same person as the evil witch queen? The party didn’t know what to make of it. They moved on to the next room.
The other room was filled with mannequins wearing different dresses. They recognized one of them as the same one that the Tasha puppet back at the carnival had been wearing. Another one actually had “Natasha” embroidered on it.
Vex and Philomena discussed the situation. If Zybilna really was Tasha, surely all her good deeds would counter whatever evil she had done as Tasha the witch? After all, Zybilna was nothing but helpful to those in need. Every couple of minutes, they’d bring the topic up again, finding a new way to rationalize the whole thing.
Next, the party checked out the hatches in the teleportation room. Vex opened one of them, and behind it was a recess in the wall containing a disembodied bugbear head. As he opened it, the head said “ga!”. Vex jumped back and closed the hatch. Then he opened it again.
“Ga!” it said. “Ga ga ga ga ga!” Vex opened and closed the hatch over and over. Philomena opened the second one, which contained a harpy head saying “ba!” The third one had a head that said “ya!” and the fourth was one also saying “ba!”
The group opened them in the order that made them say “Baba Yaga,” and everyone was teleported away. They now found themselves in the tower they’d seen from a balcony earlier, the one rising above a storm of clouds and lightning in the center of the palace. A part of the marble tower appeared to have exploded, with chunks of the wall frozen in the stormy air outside. Looking out, they also spotted a human knight in plate armor. The group thought he looked much too good to be a member of the League of Malevolence, and so, logically, he was part of Valor’s Call. That would make him Mr. Strongheart, whom the party had heard of at some point. Much like the rest of the castle, Strongheart was frozen and stuck. If he were to be unfrozen, he’d probably fall to his demise. They’d need some way to save him.
Using a rope seemed like a pretty good idea, so Vex pulled some out of his hat. But today, the hat wasn’t in a cooperative mood, and told him that the rope had been recalled because it was a fire hazard. Instead, it gave him the new iRope 8.0, which was white and only a few feet long. It also screamed for some reason. Vex walked over to the hole in the wall, and dropped the rope out in the storm.
Philomena had some korred hair, and she and LiROARidas did a dance to make it reach out and grab Strongheart. Then, Vex levitated up into the air, and used the rope, or rather hair, to pull himself toward the knight. The rest of the party held onto the rope, ready to pull it back in as soon as Vex unfroze Strongheart. Vex poked him with the unicorn horn and said his name. The party pulled, bringing both Vex and Strongheart back into the tower before the rope could swing them very far.
Once Strongheart had caught his bearings and the party had filled him in on what had happened, he was able to tell them that the League of Malevolence were hanging out in the throne room last he saw them, and one of them was sitting on the throne, which most likely gave him power over the palace’s defense systems. It’d be quite a fight if the party chose to go there, and so they didn’t.
Instead, they went upstairs, where the book they were looking for was. It stood atop a pedestal at the center of the room with a flaming quill hovering over it. The flames were magical, and didn’t burn Vex’s hand as he took the quill and opened the book. Inside were plenty of names; Igrik, Thinnings, Bavlorna, Skabatha, Endelyn, and many others the party didn’t recognize. At the end, someone had added, in a different handwriting, the names of everyone in the League of Malevolence. Vex added the names of the Beatles, just like he had in Bavlorna’s book way back in Downfall. Then the group went upstairs, because they saw more stairs.
On the top floor of the tower, they came face to face with the one door they couldn’t open despite signing their names in the book. It had eight locks and the symbol of a nightingale painted on it. Shadow got to work on the locks, but whenever he’d get one open, the previous one would lock itself again. The group tried using the chime they’d gotten from Sir Talavar, but it only unlocked one of the locks.
The door’s handle had something written in what looked like an abyssal script, so Vex cast Comprehend Languages. It said “speak my true name and enter.”
Vex stood before the door. “Natasha,” he said, somewhat nervously. Nothing happened. “Oh, good. Guess it’s not her after all.” Then he tried Zybilna. It didn’t work either.
The group tried a handful of other combinations, including “open sesame” and “mellon”, but nothing seemed to work. It wasn’t until Vex put his hand on the handle and tried “Natasha” again that he could finally open the door.
“Ha, see, Shadow? That’s how you open a—wait, oh no, that means Zybilna really is Tasha!”
He and Philomena got into another discussion about how that’s probably okay and how Zybilna is definitely still good even if she’s an evil witch.
Inside was an ornate greatsword floating in the air above a treasure chest. Vex put the sword in his hat2 and Philomena opened the chest. She was on a roll with opening things, and that wasn’t about to end. Inside the chest was a magical cloak with a unicorn embroidered on it, a scabbard for the sword, a cool antlered golden helm, and a bunch of other sweet loot that I already forgot about. Philomena took the cloak and Vex took the helmet, putting his hat on top of it.
It All Comes Down to This
Heading back down to the room where Strongheart was resting, there was really only one thing left for the Beatles to do before their quest was over: go to the ballroom and unfreeze Zybilna. She could easily deal with the rest on her own. All they had to do was find the room. They noticed that there were a few panels, like the ones in the teleportation room, in here as well, and they used them in much the same way, thinking it would bring them back where they came from. But instead, the DM decided to roll a d60 to determine which of the palace’s fifty-one rooms the group would end up in. The die came up twenty-two, which just so happened to be the ballroom.
The marble hall was huge. The walls on either side of the party had massive holes in them, and debris littered the floor. At the room’s center stood an iron cauldron, dark smoke rising from its bubbling liquid. A white-haired woman in a white gown was reaching for it, frozen in time. Zybilna. A few others were there too, though the party didn’t know them. Slithering around the cauldron and Zybilna lay the massive serpentine body of the jabberwock, asleep. The party tiptoed over to an adjoining room to discuss their plan.
“Alright, LiROARidas,” whispered Vex3. “You heard what Thinnings said. Distract him with your music and I’ll free Zybilna. Then, I’ll get her to stop the Jabberwock before it can get you. We’ll go into the other room and hide. Wait one minute, and then play.”
“Alright,” said LiROARidas. “Good luck.”
The rest of the party went to hide behind some rubble. After a minute, the dreary sound of LiROARidas’ depressing double flute, the Pipes of Haunting, reverberated through the grand ballroom. The jabberwock opened its bulging white eyes and raised its head toward the direction of the sound. It got up and crawled across the rubble toward LiROARidas. He paused his playing for a moment, and ran into the next room, which was a pool room that was—fortunately—shrouded in steam. There, he played some more.
Vex stood crouched behind a large chunk of wall, and slipped on some gravel as the jabberwock went by. It heard him, turned its head and used its bedazzling gaze to vex Vex4. For a while, he found that he couldn’t move. The jabberwock ignored him, being more interested in the music, and entered the pool room through another massive hole in the wall. It slowly slithered its long neck through the room, looking for the haunting piper. Just then, Vex snapped out of his confusion, got up and rushed toward Zybilna. He touched her with the unicorn horn, and said “Natasha.”
She broke free of the spell, stumbling forward briefly before regaining her footing. She looked around, confused. “Who are you?” she asked Vex.
“It’s me, Vex the great, your humble warlock!” he answered.
“You—yes, I remember you. Wha—”
“I can explain everything, but my friend is about to get eaten by the jabberwock.”
“Oh, of course,” she said, and whistled. The jabberwock stopped, and flew out of the palace through yet another hole in the pool room’s outer wall.
The rest of the party joined them in the ballroom. Thinking for a moment, Zybilna realized she recognized them all. She’d helped every single one of them at some point in their past. The group explained everything about Madryck Roslof, the Witchlight Carnival, the hags, Prismeer, and the League of Malevolence. When they mentioned those guys, Zybilna snapped her fingers. Nobody ever saw any members of the league after that.
At first, Zybilna seemed shocked to hear that the members of the Hourglass Coven were all dead, but the more the party told her about what they’d done, the more pleased she seemed about it. Once she’d taken in everything they had to say, Zybilna realized she had quite a bit of work ahead of her to restore the palace and Prismeer to its former glory. But first, she promised everyone a wish.
LiROARidas, of course, asked for his eyesight back. He got it. She also took the freaky parasite eye off his shoulder and gave it a pair of chicken legs so it could move around on its own.
Philomena took out her taxidermied rabbit and wished for it to be brought back to life. Zybilna took care of it, and even made it intelligent so Philomena could speak to it.
Shadow said there was a cat back home, named Fiona, whom he fancied, and he wanted to know how she felt about him. Zybilna brought her right to the palace, and once they’d told her where she was and what was happening, she threw herself into Shadow’s arms.
Eiri’s player wasn’t there, so she got jack shit.
Boris the disappointed bird also got a wish. After speaking telepathically to Zybilna for a while, she set the bird down and cast a spell. Suddenly, where the bird had stood there was now a beautiful tiefling woman. She said her name was River, and that she was from another world. She had come from the city of Drakkenheim and escaped just before the world was destroyed. She’d popped up at the Witchlight Carnival, and got turned into a bird for not having a ticket. She immediately started flirting with Philomena.
Once it was Vex’s turn, he said, “Well, I got what I came for, and I have everything I want waiting for me back home. But if I had to wish for one thing, it’d be the truth.”
“What do you mean?” asked Zybilna.
“Well, to unfreeze someone from the spell, you have to use the unicorn horn and say their true name.”
A look of rage began to creep across Zybilna’s face as she realized what was happening.
“…and I didn’t say Zybilna,” Vex continued.
Zybilna’s hair turned black, as did her clothes and her mood. She looked both older and younger at the same time. “Who are you to question me?” she roared. “You don’t know what I’ve accomplished—the battles I’ve fought, the enemies I’ve acquired. Who are you to come into my own palace and question me?”
Everyone except LiROARidas tried to calm her down all at once.
“Don’t misunderstand,” said Vex. “We found out the truth, and still came to free you. We just want to know how this came to be, and who you really are.”
Zybilna calmed down. “It’s true,” she said. “I am Natasha, the Witch Queen. I’m the adopted daughter of Baba Yaga. I became Zybilna to escape my enemies. They’d never guess that an archfey who helps the poor would really be me.” She paused for a moment. “But I came to enjoy it. I liked doing good, and I liked spreading joy. So I kept doing it. But my sisters, Bavlorna, Skabatha, and Endelyn—Baba Yaga’s real daughters—grew jealous. And so they froze me in time.”
After a few moments of silence, she spoke again: “Are you sure there’s nothing else you want?”
“Well,” said Vex. “I wouldn’t mind some more blueberry muffins to share with my friends.”
Epilogue
With their grand adventure completed, and satisfied that freeing Tasha the Witch Queen was the morally correct thing to do, the party got to return to the Witchlight Carnival. Mr. Witch and Mr. Light were endlessly thankful for their help.
In the years that followed, a lot of weddings took place. First, there was the wedding of Candlefoot and Palasha. Then, Vex and Kirian. Then there was Shadow and Fiona. And finally, Philomena and River.
And let’s not forget LiROARidas’ wish—to finally get to go to one of Vex’s magic shows. Indeed that wish came true, and Vex put on a slightly drunken show during a big party the group had after returning back home. LiROARidas even got to volunteer to be sawed in half. Vex accidentally reattached his legs backward5.
Also, the teddy bear LiROARidas had? It turned evil from absorbing so much grief and attacked LiROARidas in his sleep. Don’t worry, he was fine. I think.
Epi-epilogue
Well, it’s not every day you get to wrap up a D&D campaign, but this is one of those days. It’s the longest series on this site, and I somehow survived writing about every session without falling behind even a single week. How ‘bout that, eh?
It was a great campaign, and I can see why it’s highly rated. The main highlights for me were the whole Witchlight Carnival intro, with the real circus tickets and cotton candy and lots of minigames; stepping through the mirror to Hither first time and not having a clue what would come next; and the shadow puppet theater and the improvised play at Motherhorn, where we got really into the improv. I think most of the things that could’ve been done better were the fault of the writers at Wizard of the Coast. And I’m not just saying that because the DM might read this.
Anyway, I think with the reduced focus on combat in this campaign, we ended up focusing more on the characters, which was a nice change of pace that we haven’t had since way back when we played Werewolf the Forsaken. I’m hoping we can bring some of that into the next adventure, even though it’ll have a good bit more fighting. I’ll be running that one—been working on a homebrew thing for a while now. I haven’t really run anything other than one-shots since I did Monster of the Week, so it’ll be nice to get back in the DM seat. Will I be able to write about every session while also preparing the adventure as it goes? Only one way to find out!
While the “ROAR” in LiROARidas is supposed to be a proper lion’s roar, I’ve started pronouncing it in a way that can apparently be written phonetically as {V‼6ə7} ↩︎
Eiri would’ve gotten it, but her player had to leave early. Rather unfortunate, with this turning out to be the finale and all. Oh well. ↩︎
How does one whisper a roar? Don’t ask me. ↩︎
There it is. The joke. Finally. ↩︎
Remember how Vex paid Trinket and Bauble with getting disadvantage on his next performance check? This was it. ↩︎
My footnotes have footnotes. My house is also bigger on the inside than the outside. ↩︎
Part of a series called The Wild Beyond the Witchlight.
Previous: Witchlight Part 17: Philomena and Vex Go to the Palace
Tagged as D&D 5e, Me as a player, Session report.